Chapter 11 Whigs and Democrats

HISTORY THROUGH FILM

Amistad (1997)

Directed by Steven Spielberg. Starring

The Africans spend most of the movie

Matthew McConaughey (Roger Baldwin),

in a dark jail or in court, and the film cen-

Morgan Freeman (Theodore Joadson),

ters on them and their experiences with

Anthony Hopkins (John Quincy Adams),

two groups of Americans: the abolitionists

Djimon Hounsou (Cinque).

who are trying to free them, and the politi-

cal and legal officials who want to hang

In 1839, an American cruiser seized the

them—largely to keep their own political

Cuban slave ship Amistad off the shore

system intact. Spielberg’s abolitionists are

of Long Island. The ship carried 41 Afri-

Lewis Tappan, a black activist (Morgan

cans who had revolted, killed the captain

Freeman), an obscure young white lawyer

and crew, and commandeered the ship—

(Matthew McConaughey), and, in the

along with two Spanish slave dealers who

grand finale, Congressman and former

bargained for their lives by promising

President John Quincy Adams (played

to sail the ship east to Africa, then steer-

wonderfully by Anthony Hopkins). In the

ed for North America. The Africans were

historical case, the defense was handled by

imprisoned at New Haven and tried

veteran abolitionists or by persons who

for piracy and murder in federal court.

had been working with abolitionists for a

The government of Spain demanded

long time. Spielberg shaped this group to

their return, and southern leaders pres-

tell his own story, beginning with reluctant

sured President Van Buren for a

and confused reformers and politicians

“friendly” decision. The legal case cen-

who, along with the audience, gradually

tered on whether the Africans were

realize the moral imperatives of the case.

Cuban slaves or kidnapped Africans.

In one of the film’s more powerful

(The international slave trade was by

sequences, the Africans’ leader, Cinque

then illegal.) The New Haven court

(Djimon Hounsou), through a translator,

acquitted them, the federal government

tells his story to the lawyer: his village life

appealed the case, and the Supreme

in Sierra Leone (the one scene filmed in

Court freed them again. The Africans

bright sunlight), his capture by Africans,

were returned to Sierra Leone.

his transportation to the slave fort of

forms of state sovereignty, Jackson and the Democratic coalition insisted that the Union was inviolable and that any attempt to dissolve it would be met with force.

At the same time, a Democratic Party uniting northern and southern agrarians into a states’-rights, limited-government majority could guarantee southern rights within the Union. This answer to the southern question stayed in place until the breakup of the Democratic Party on the eve of the Civil War.

JACKSONIAN DEMOCRACY AND THE MARKET REVOLUTION

Jacksonian Democrats cherished the simplicity of Jefferson’s agrarian republic.

They assumed power at the height of the Market Revolution, and they spent much

of the 1830s and 1840s trying to reconcile the market and the republic. Like the

Jeffersonians before them, Democrats welcomed commerce as long as it served the

Jacksonian Democracy and the Market Revolution

401

Lomboko, the horrors of the passage on

lead the Revolution, speaks for his and

the Portuguese slaver Tecora, the slave

Cinque’s ancestors before the Supreme

market in Havana, and the bloody revolt

Court: to the prosecution’s argument

on the Amistad—all of it portrayed

that the Africans are pirates and mur-

wrenchingly on the screen. The Africans’

derers and to southern arguments that

story continues in jail, as they study pic-

slavery is a natural state, he answers that

tures in a Bible and try to figure out the

America is founded on the “self-evident

American legal, political, and moral sys-

truth” that the one natural state is free-

tem. In court, they finally cut through the

dom. It is a fine Hollywood courtroom

mumbo-jumbo by standing and chanting

speech: Adams has honored his ancestors,

“Give Us Free!”

the justices and the audience see the moral

In a fictive interview on the eve of the

rightness of his case, and the Africans are

Supreme Court case, Cinque tells Adams

returned to Sierra Leone. (In a subscript,

that he is optimistic because he has called

Spielberg tells us that Cinque returns to a

on the spirits of his ancestors to join him

village that had been destroyed in civil

in court. This moment, he says, is the

war, but the final ironic note is over-

whole reason for their having existed at

whelmed by the moral triumphalism of

all. Adams, whose own father had helped

the rest of the movie.)

Amistad (1997) tells the

story of 41 Africans who

stage a revolt on the slave

Andrew

ship carrying them to

Cuba and the trial that

follows.

COLLECTION/Cooper,

KOBAL

LLC/THE

Dreamworks

liberty and rough equality of white men, but paper currency and the dependence on credit that came with the Market Revolution posed problems. The so-called paper

economy separated wealth from “real work” and encouraged an unrepublican

spirit of luxury and greed. Worst of all, the new paper economy required

government-granted privileges that the Jacksonians, still speaking the language of revolutionary republicanism, branded “corruption.” For the same reasons, the protective tariffs and government-sponsored roads and canals of the American System

were unacceptable. The Jackson presidency aimed to curtail government involve-

ment in the economy, to end special privilege, and thus to rescue the republic from the Money Power.

The opposition to the Democrats (by 1834 they called themselves Whigs)

favored an activist central government that would encourage orderly economic

development through the American System of protective tariffs, a federally

402