banner

Secession Era Editorials Project

Furman University Department of History

banner
 

The Assault on Hon. W. T. Butler.

Austin, Texas, Texas State Gazette [Democratic]

(14 June 1856)

The most serious offence committed in the American Senate, and one which must be promptly rebuked, is the slanderous and dastardly attack upon the South and one of her proudest patriots, by Sumner, the abolitionist leader in the Senate. The mere application of corporal chastisement inflicted by an individual member, is liable to too much annoyance and inconvenience. Brooks did his work well, but then it is wrong that the Senate should be made the place for whole-sale denunciations against the South for utterance of the grossest libel and vituperative abuse against Southern men, without other remedy for the evil than that dictated in the breast of each member. If this is liberty of speech, it is that licence which immediately precedes the eloquence of an antagonist's blow. It is a liberty unusual in private life -- it is an abuse which will call forth chastisement in any respectable circle of American society. Deliberation among equals can no longer go on. The sessions of the American Senate must come to a close.

The offence of Sumner ought to be visited with expulsion. He is not merely an enthusiast -- he is a dirty dog. Either he or the high-minded and chivalrous Butler, is not in his proper position. Will the U. S. Senate longer tolerate the conduct displayed by Mr. Sumner? The consequences are not equivocal.

[<<Previous Editorial][Next Editorial>>]