banner

Secession Era Editorials Project

Furman University Department of History

banner
 

Mr. Giddings' Letter to Mr. Benton.

Columbus, Ohio, State Journal [Republican]

(25 March 1857)

ThomH. Benton, in his copy-righted, Union-saving lecture, states "that the Constitution of the United States sets out with the declaration that 'slaves are property,'" to which Mr. Giddings replies in a long letter. The following are the points which he argues:

That the declaration is repugnant to the judgment of mankind; that it is opposed to the teachings of nature and revelation; that it is in direct contradiction to the understanding and purposes of those who achieved our National Independence; that it is opposed to the expressed intentions of those who formed our Constitution; that it is contradicted by the spirit and letter of that instrument; that the Federal Constitution (according to the decision of Judge McLean) does not regard slaves as property. Mr. Giddings argues these points with great ability and and heat.

[<<Previous Editorial][Next Editorial>>]