Continuing lecture on Freud

Psychoanalytical Arguement for Determinism
1) neurotic behavior
2) Hypnosis

-Personality is developed by age 5
-unconscious motives drive behavior

id- animal nature; primal desires; pleasure; immediate gratification

superego- "inner hitler";represses desires

ego- diplomat; moderates between id and superego; conscious

Criticisms of psychoanalytical arguement
1) Maybe people are free in areas in which they are not neurotic

Libertarianism

-Arg. from regret-James
Rebuttal- its a false belief in free will which causes regret

-Arg. from poor prediction in psychology
-unpredictable
-case studies provide unreliable data